Printable View
Hi there all you lawn specialists,I need your help.:doh:
I want to purchase a whipper snipper,got no Idea what I need:no:
Got a double block ,whats the diff.betw.4 & 2 stroke performance?
STIHL OR HONDA? or any other sugestions would be greatly appreciated.
Whats the diff.betw.bent shaft & stright shaft anny advantiges?
Your help would be greatly appriciated
Happy New Year to All
Harry
G'day Saltbox.
When I had a lawn mowing round several years ago I had all 2 stroke and they were virtually indestructible. Victa mowers (2str had better torque at low revs) Shingu w/snippers and Stihl blowers.
W/s was a straight shaft ( I was told were the best but cant remember why) which is still going strong despite being hammered most days. I made sure the spool head was regularly greased, filters cleaned and changed the spark plug regularly.
Pros & cons
- 2 stroke engines give out lots more pollution than 4 strokes and it's a pain to mix the petrol & engine oil.
- The disadvantage of 4 stroke engines is that there are very few around for whipper snippers (plenty for lawn mowers) and they are the more expensive brands (Honda, perhaps Stihl??) but of course if your budget permits, these would be beaut machines.
I was told that straight shaft ones are better, but I'd think that either would work well.
Other things to look out for
- weight (IF you are not big or strong, then some of the brands/models may make using them a heavy task literally :) )
- noise level
- vibration level
- how often you'll use them - if you use them frequently and can justify coughing out the budget, both of those you mentioned (Honda & Stihl) are excellent, and between the two, it would pretty much boil down to personal preference & perhaps the specific model you like.
For lower end budget, Ryobi is supposedly quite good vis a vis the money.
So bottom line, if budget permits, go for 4 stroke, if all else is equal perhaps choose the straight shaft. Re brands, there are some other professional brands out there, but you can't go wrong with Honda / Stihl.
I recently bought the bottom of the line Honda 4-stroke, and couldn't be happier. It is an awesome machine, very quiet, and starts second pull every time! First pull, choke on, second pull choke off, and away she goes!
The difference between the bent and straight shafts is that the straight shafts are brush-cutters, so you can put a solid cutter on it and do some slashing if you want.
Straight shafts are kinder to your back as well as being mechanically stronger.
I had a Ryobi trimmer but eventually it became a PITA to start. I bought a Makita trimmer as there was a remainder in the local Mitre 10 that was too good to pass up. It was a very good buy. It usually starts on the 2nd or 3rd pull once you know how. The trick is to make sure you prime the carb first using the bulb.
G'day All.
I have a Husky 22Lr straight shaft brushcutter. Line trimmer and steel blade. As a brushcutter it cannot be beat. But as a line trimmer, it is a pain. no bump feed, spins toward your feet. thus throwing gravel and schit at you (shins look like a war zone afterwards). Heavy. and after trimming an acre block with paths and 22 metre concrete driveway edges, my upper arm kills me.
Santa brought me a Talon Grass Hawk bent shaft with bump feed. It replaces a Weedeater bent shaft that wont run anymore.
The Talon was used yesterday for the first time.. Bloody fantastic :2tsup:.
For a cheap machine it works great. Starts first pull after priming.
And it spins away from me. no more bleeding shins :2tsup:
I did a job about 18 years ago when we hire the brush cutters with solid blades to clear an embankment. We snapped the shafts of three machines before they refused to hire us any more!:D
I just seized the motor in my Dolmar..POS thing ....like all 2 strokes AFAIK. replaced it with a 25hp..(or is it cc?) Honda 4 stroke what a nice bit of kit!
As spelunx points out starts second pull, quiet, very responsive from idle to full throttle...and I dont have to worry about the jets gumming up when its not used over winter.
BTW it was advertised at $625 but I got them down to $500.....trade special or something.
Thanks I think you made my mind up for me.Honda or Stihl it is!!!! just have to check the weight on both,got some back problems.(heavent we all???)
Dear Saltbox,
I've got a Stihl FS36 trimmer at the moment: 2-stroke, curved shaft, brilliant. Bought it because she's a 50:1 mix ratio, which perfectly matched the mix ratio of the Suzuki 2-stroke motor in my Rover XL mower, which has also been brilliant (except for the Suzi's "Achilles Heel" - the dreaded leaky petrol cap!).
2-stroke are generally good for lightweightness and fuel economy, and if you're doing a lot of lawns, because you never have to worry about changing the sump oil, because there isn't any. Having said that, a lot of the Pros take a different approach and go for the 4-stroke Hondas in order to get good reliability, reduced noice, and less vibration - and therefore less "Tennis Elbow". As regards the oil change, the Pro's end up doing so many lawns that they simply get into a maintenance routine, and they end up getting the oil change "Down Pat", so to speak. I had a feel of a Honda 4-stroke mower with an alloy base yesterday, and I don't think she was any heavier than my Rover...
Is a pretty good idea to match fuel types and ratios between your trimmer and your mower, because unleaded fuel can go "stale", and using one mix for both devices helps you to get through a can of petrol quicker. Don't think you can get 50:1 mix 2-stroke mowers brand new anymore, just 25:1. My Rover's getting a bit long in the tooth, but for the Stihl's sake I'll keep her going until I can reduce the number of lawns I have to mow to just one or two. Then I'll be looking at replacing both with 4-stroke Hondas - both mower and trimmer.
I had a feel of the Honda trimmer yesterday, and in spite of the usual weight penalty for going to 4-stroke, the thing was definitely no heavier than my 2-stroke Stihl. If your just doing some edges, all you'll need is the bottom of the range domestic garden-variety curved shaft Honda (RRP $399). If you need to do some brushcutting, though, you'll have to step up to a straight shaft, because you're not allowed to put solid blades on a curved shaft trimmer. I find curved shaft to be the most comfortable.
Hope this helps,
Batpig.
G'day All.
What is the problems from using 50:1 for everything?
My Husky Chainsaw is 50:1
Victa Mower 25:1
Talon trimmer 25:1
Husky Brushcutter 50:1
I've been using 50:1 for all of them.
Is this a no-no? If so, why?
Dear markharrison,thanks for your reply.Quote:
Originally Posted by markharrison
Have you heard of a Whippersnipper ZENOAH KOMATSU,currently on e-bay
also on e-bay MACHTIG saw Brush cutter chain saw & whipper snipper(Made in Japan) anny comments on both would be appreciated:doh:
regards Harry
Quote:
Originally Posted by Batpig
Dear Batpig,
Thank youl your reply was very helpful,have you heard of ZENOAH KOMATSU & MACHTIG whippersnippers???
Regards Harry
Dear Harry,
Sadly I've got to say - No, I haven't heard of either of those two brands, at least in the trimmer department. I have seen Machtig mitre saws going through on e-bay, though. I'm not certain whether they are a real brand, however, rather than a GMC or Ozito type of thing, where the closest they would come to owning their own factory would be to own something more like a sticker factory (ie. to make all of the different shaped stickers to go on the sides of all of those generically produced Chinese tools). I could be wrong, mind you. Komatsu itself is a well known brand, but in the Earthmoving department. The brand you quoted containing that name might be trying to ride on their coat-tails.
But the long and the short of it is that I haven't heard of either brand of trimmer. Me-thinks you would be treading on quite thin ice if you bought either brand, especially from a spare-parts point of view. You can't go wrong with Stihl or Honda. What sort of mower have you got now? 2-stroke or 4-stroke? If 2, what's your mix ratio? Do you have much lawn to mow?
Regards,
Batpig.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Batpig
Dear Batpig,Thanks for your fast reply.
I just bought a VICTA 4 stroke MULCH OR CATCH What a beauty it is(OK its new)but I couldn't get enough of looking at my lawn LOL the mulching is absolutely a delight there is no bits of grass laying on top it gets blown right in.Having said this I'm leaning towards the Honda 4 stroke no need for any oil mixing.Your reply made a lot of sense to me,you should stick to BRAND NAMES gritt your teeth and pay the extra.What are CREDIT CARDS FOR????LOL:U
P.S.I got a level double block to cut approx.every week
Take care & thanks
Harry
Yep, go the Honda Harry...
It's the UMS425 that you're after. As stated, RRP is $399, but maybe cash will talk a little for you. Curved shaft, but that's all you need. Curved shaft on my Stihl makes it easy for me to "Bevel" my edges by virtually "sweeping" the lawn up and off the concrete paths by walking along the concrete side of the edge and holding the trimmer at a particular angle that just gives the lawn this nice bevelled edge. Your left hand would be holding the upper-right side of the Honda's handle upwards, with you pointing the whole thing at the grass at an angle of about 45deg in plan (ie. from above) with the cord flicking everything up and away from you. If things are too tight to walk along the concrete side of the edge, you can get approximately the same bevel by walking along the grass side of the edge, but holding the upper-left side of the Honda's handle upwards with your left hand, in a sort of "Backcut" mode, wherein you usually walk backwards, sort of "pulling" the thing along the grass (again at angle of about 45deg when viewed from above), and everything gets flicked back at you. All the little pebbles bounce off your shoes and the ground, so make sure you're wearing long pants and goggles! Backcut should be your default mode when you are doing the edge along the kerb out next to the road, so that you don't get run over by some Knob on a Mobile Phone. At any rate, the bevel edge that is achieved by the combination of these methods is "Sweet As..." so to speak, and much nicer than that "Trenched" look that you get from a lot of the contractors.
If you do get the Honda, maybe you could start a new thread down here in a couple of months, just to let us all know what she's like when you've had a bit of experience with her.
Best Wishes,
Batpig.
Oh Trevor/Glock,
Sorry, nearly forgot you... Can't say for sure, but I think that running a 2-stroke with less oil than specified in the mix (such as what you're doing now with the Victa and the Talon) could invite eventual bottom end bearing and compression problems, whereas running a 2-stroke with more oil than specified (such as would be the case with your Husky's if you started running everything at 25:1 instead) would cost you a drop in power, and increased carbon deposits in your cylinder, spark-plug, port, and exhaust. You might, just might, be able to tune your way around the problem by fidling with the Idle/High/Low screws on the Husky's carbies, but it's all a bit "cause and effect" wherein you wont really see the effects for a couple of months. If you do persist in running everything at 50:1, make sure you're using a good 2-stroke oil that definitely says on the side of the bottle that it is suitable for use in 50:1 mixes.
Good Luck,
Batpig.
Dear Batpig,
Thanks again for all your info,you sure know your stuff,I'm 6foot 2" tall,
been told stright shaft works better for tall people,I also got a back problem,whats your opinion on the matter??
greatly appr.your help:B
Thanks Harry
Hard to say Harry, because I'm only a little fella compared to you. What's more I've never had a straight-shaft trimmer because I had a Ryobi before the Stihl, and it was a curved shaft too. Haven't heard anyone say it either, but it could well be true. However, if you look at the angle between the head and the straight section of the shaft on both types, it is about the same angle. The curved part of the shaft on the curved shaft version simply pushes the head down by a bit more. So maybe the truth of the matter is the other way around to what you have heard...Quote:
I guess I'd be going into the mower shop and picking up both of the Hondas and seeing what they felt like, and what sort of angles the cord was likely to hit the ground at. Maybe one of the shop blokes who was about your height might go outside with you and the two types of trimmer and just show you how he reckons you would use either one. Don't be too embarrassed to get him to do it a few times so that you can watch his body posture a couple of times on each unit, as well as the cord-to-ground angle a couple of times on each. Then try copying him on each one yourself. Try my technique as well. One things for sure, when you've got the trimmer at the correct angle, it's no good if your body isn't fairly straight. A little bit of bending over for a short while may not feel too bad, but it really starts to get to you after you've been doing it for a while, especially if you've got a bad back (mine's not brilliant either, Harry...)
Anyway, for what it's worth, the cheapest straight shaft that they do is the UMK425 for $629, but the price difference would be well worth it if it came down to a matter of comfort. Bear in mind when you're talking to them at the shop, though, that they've probably got a slightly vested interest in selling you the straight shaft unit due to higher profit based on price.
Good Luck,
Batpig.
Thanks batpig,you are very helpfull.
You are so right,it allways comes down to the money,AINT THAT THE TRUTH.
You are on your own,if it wasnt for blokes like YOU.
Thanks Mate
Harry:B
Quote:
Originally Posted by glock40sw
I purchased a Talon Petrol Line Trimmer mid-2007 and was told by the salesman that it was a good brand - he had one and it worked well for him, yadda... however after Hub used it once (or twice, who notices these things??) it now won't start. The pull cord works ok, it turns ok, head bit spins etc, but the blasted thing just won't kick over. The petrol was the right mix and it gets primed, the valve is closed as it says to do on the machine and we seem to be doing it all properly. Any ideas as to why the darling machine won't start?
:doh:
I'd appreciate any and all responses...
Cheers
Lennii