Reguritating an old thread I know but hey Im in and out like a friggin yoyo so I catch em as I can :D
For me the biggest tear jerker is...
Sunshine by John Denver... first heard it as I sat holding a girlfriends hand as she passed away... we were heading to Perth from Carnarvon for a holiday she had taken her car I mine as she had to return to work before me, I was following her and as we went around a bend just after the Billabong roadhouse a semi trailers back trailer swerved across and collected her... we were on the side of the road late at night in the rain the cars totaled and shes broken but the radio plays bloody "Sunshine" as my girl faded and left me ... most terrible night of my life :( I still see her clear as day if I ever hear "Sunshine"... its been banned in my home ever since and still is. (her highness is cool with it although she loves the album... respect you know?)
Danny boy also does me in... First time I played it at a funeral was my granddads in Adelaide and although I managed to get through without falling apart when I played it at my mums funeral a couple of years ago my sisters and brother had to come up to help me finish it... ended up sounding okay and the fact that all her kids had sung it together was pretty cool she would have liked that
Years ago I used to play lead and some vocals in a band up north mostly funny songs beer songs old man emu guitar man out behind the shed fun stuff you know... we used to do a lot of Dr Hook for hysterics value... and there was one that was a sort of one of those "not done" songs called "One more year of lollipops" about a dad whos daughter has a year to live... I made it a song we wouldnt cover since I knew I would bawl my heart out as I always did when I heard it or tried to sing it... until the drummer and his girlfriend lost their little 8 year old son to Luekemia and I was asked to sing it both at the funeral and at the first gig after... man talk about a blubbering mess... but luckily the others picked me up and carried the song... I still cant sing it or hear it without crying for that gorgeous little fella gone so young :(
Your right its the memories and emotions that the words conjure in ones mind that sets the tears to flowing... I can listen to Amazing Grace without a murmur but put on any of those above and Im history